Coronavirus Threat Looms Large for Low-Income Cities

CORONAVIRUS THREAT LOOMS LARGE FOR LOW-INCOME CITIES

by Eric Fèvre and Cecilia Tacoli | March 5, 2020

This post was first published by the International Institute for Environment and Development.

Read more A4NH research and perspectives on coronavirus and the ongoing global pandemic.

In our increasingly interconnected world, outbreaks of infectious diseases – such as Ebola, SARS and now the current coronavirus (COVID-19) – can quickly turn from epidemics (spreading rapidly) to pandemics (spreading cross-continent, or globally).

Densely packed urban environments where humans live alongside bats, rodents, birds, pets and domestic animals are especially fertile grounds for the spread of new disease. Here, viruses – or indeed other pathogens – can easily jump from species to species and evolve to be infectious to multiple hosts.

While scientists cannot say for sure where and in what species COVID-19 acquired the ability to infect humans, the outbreak has been traced to a ‘wet’ market in the Chinese city of Wuhan. The image of packed humid marketplaces selling dead and live animals, where people bustle down narrow aisles with wet, slippery floors have thrust these traditional markets into the global spotlight.

But are calls to abolish wet markets fair?

Target wild trade, not wet trade

Wet markets can provide valuable nutrition to urban communities. Recognising their role in urban food security, China has invested heavily in upgrading many of its cities’ traditional food markets.

Read a recent commentary based on A4NH research into how retail diversity can help ensure diet diversity, and what that means for wet markets and supermarkets in Vietnam.

Wet markets are considered part of the informal food trade that is often blamed for contributing to spreading disease. But as documented in an issue paper in the latest edition of the Environment & Urbanization journal, evidence shows the link between informal markets and disease is not always so clear cut.

And rather than pointing the finger at wet markets, we must look at the wild animal trade – for it is wild animals rather than farmed animals that are the natural hosts of many viruses. Indeed, China has responded with a “comprehensive” ban on the trade and consumption of wild animals.

A looming threat

So far, COVID-19 has been reported in only high- and middle-income nations where effective health systems are in place, and conditions are generally sanitary. But what will happen if the disease spreads to cities in low-income nations?

Many low-income settlements lack basic infrastructure and services. Unsafe water, inadequate sanitation, open drainage and refuse dumps are all factors attracting rodents and other parasites. These are prime reasons for the high prevalence of infectious diseases.

In crowded spaces, people are forced to share accommodation and – when available – toilets. Residents are constantly on the move, often travelling on packed mini-buses – to workplaces within settlements, between settlements, between the city and rural homes. Attempting to control this kind of movement would be extremely difficult.

The shortfalls of expert recommendations

The emergence of COVID-19 in low-income cities would present the classic ‘wicked problem’ and would, without doubt, be a major challenge to contain.

For example, current recommendations for preventing the spread of the disease include washing hands frequently – but this is extremely difficult where clean water access is limited.

Isolation is another recommendation – but this is almost impossible to put into practice in settlements where population density is extremely high. Self-quarantining – staying at home for at least 14 days – is scarcely an option for the urban poor who often rely on daily wages from casual labour.

A new approach

Short-term efforts are focused on containing the spread of infection. The longer term – given that new infectious diseases will likely continue to spread rapidly into and within cities – calls for an overhaul of current approaches to urban planning and development.

Low-income settlements need more effective infrastructure. Often labelled by city authorities as ‘informal’ or ‘illegal’, these settlements do not receive investment for basic services such as piped water, sanitation or electricity. They are not served by primary healthcare facilities or regular solid waste collection. And yet these settlements often house over half of a city’s population, being the only affordable option for many residents.

Recognising the existence of affordable (though grossly inadequate) forms of housing that in effect subsidise labour costs for the rest of the city’s inhabitants is a first step not only towards addressing the challenging living conditions of low-income settlements, but as a way of helping contain the spread of new and deadly contagious disease.


Eric Fèvre is professor of veterinary infectious diseases at the University of Liverpool, who conducts research as part of A4NH's research flagship on Improving Human Health. Cecilia Tacoli is principal researcher in IIED's Human Settlements research group.

The authors thank Julio D Dávila, professor of Urban Policy and International Development, and director of the Development Planning Unit, University College London, and Muki Haklay, professor of Geographic Information Science in the Department of Geography, UCL, and co-director of the UCL Extreme Citizen Science group, who contributed to this blog.

Image at top taken by an electron microscope showing the virus that causes COVID-19. The spikes on the outer edges of the virus particles give coronaviruses their name: crown-like (Photo: NIAID-RML via Flickr, copyright free)

Blog

A4NH's Director shares thoughts on the pandemic's impact on low- and middle-income countries, and considerations for building back more inclusive and resilient systems.

Flagships

As the UN warns of an impending global food emergency, researchers in health, nutrition and agriculture unite to support response, recovery and resilience.

Blog

A series of blogs from experts in nutrition, health, food systems, and more on different aspects of global, regional, and national impacts of the coronavirus.